angry lion

How Can I Deal with Difficult Coworkers?

In almost every workplace, you’ve likely encountered at least one person who changes the entire atmosphere the moment they walk into the room. When they’re absent, you find yourself breathing a sigh of relief, as the day instantly seems brighter without their dominating presence or constant complaints. Whether they’re aggressively entitled or perpetually playing the victim, navigating the challenge of dealing with difficult coworkers can significantly impact your work environment and personal well-being.

Although there’s no universal remedy for handling the complex dynamics of workplace relationships, there are effective strategies you can employ to make your professional life more tolerable and even productive. Drawing from the wisdom of Dr. Mark Goulston, a psychiatrist and former FBI hostage negotiator, here are some invaluable tips for managing those challenging personalities you encounter at work—and beyond.

Recognize Difficult Personalities (Including Your Own)

It’s essential to know when you’re interacting with a difficult coworker. These individuals often exhibit self-centered behaviors and believe they deserve more than they do. Their approaches can vary from outright bullying to seeking constant attention and reassurance. Being aware of these traits can help you stay prepared and not get blindsided by their tactics.

Keep Your Emotions in Check

Difficult personalities thrive on knocking others off-balance emotionally to achieve their goals. By maintaining your composure and refusing to play their games, you cut off the reaction they’re seeking.

Take a Moment Before You Respond

Giving yourself time to think before responding can prevent the situation from escalating and reduce the aggressor’s ability to provoke a more heated reaction.

Dr. Goulston offers three powerful verbal strategies to handle nearly any difficult personality you might face:

  1. Challenge Their Beliefs: Asking, “Do you really believe what you just said?” in a calm, unemotional tone can disrupt their thought process, especially when they resort to exaggeration or baseless accusations.
  2. Express Confusion Simply: A straightforward “Huh?” can stop even the most challenging individual in their tracks. This indicates that their argument doesn’t make sense to you, prompting them to rethink their approach.
  3. Demand Mutual Benefit: When confronted with unreasonable demands, questioning, “I can see how this benefits you. Tell me how it will benefit me?” shifts the conversation towards a more equitable exchange. If they avoid answering or continue pressing, you have every right to say no.

Dealing with difficult coworkers is an unavoidable part of life, be it in your office, community gatherings, or even family events. Equipping yourself with these strategies can help you manage the stress and frustration that often accompany these interactions.

For organizations facing conflict management challenges, Leadership Excellence offers a range of solutions aimed at improving team dynamics and leadership skills. Our offerings include leadership development, business and life coaching, effective communication training, and staff development, all designed to address your organization’s specific needs. Our goal is to tackle workplace challenges head-on and foster a positive, productive environment. Based in Cleveland, we also extend our on-site leadership training to businesses in surrounding areas. Reach out to discover how our distinctive approach can make a difference in your organization.

Understanding Why Difficult Coworkers May Act the Way They Do

Understanding the roots of difficult behavior in coworkers can provide valuable insights and strategies for improving workplace dynamics. Here’s a perspective on why coworkers might be challenging to work with:

At the heart of many challenging workplace behaviors lie complex, often personal issues that can significantly impact an individual’s demeanor and interactions with others. These underlying causes are varied and multifaceted, including stress, personal insecurities, lack of fulfillment, and even external pressures that have little to do with the work itself.

Stress is a prevalent factor; it’s omnipresent in our fast-paced world. When your coworkers are under high levels of stress—whether from workload, personal life challenges, or financial pressures—they may become more irritable, less cooperative, or even aggressive. Stress can narrow an individual’s perspective, making it harder for them to see the broader picture or consider the needs and feelings of others. This tunnel vision can lead to a decrease in empathy and an increase in self-centered behavior, exacerbating tensions in team dynamics.

Insecurities and a lack of fulfillment also play a significant role. When someone feels insecure about their abilities or unsure of their role within a team, they might overcompensate by being overly critical, dismissive, or competitive. These behaviors are protective mechanisms to mask their fears of inadequacy or being perceived as incompetent. Similarly, a lack of fulfillment or engagement with their work can lead to negative behaviors as individuals express their dissatisfaction in unproductive ways, seeking attention or causing disruptions as a means to voice their unhappiness or disinterest.

Furthermore, external pressures such as personal relationships, health issues, or societal expectations can spill over into the workplace, affecting behavior. A coworker dealing with challenging circumstances outside of work may have less emotional bandwidth to engage positively with colleagues, leading to misunderstandings and friction.

Recognizing these underlying reasons doesn’t excuse difficult behavior but offers a pathway to empathy and understanding. By acknowledging the complexities of human emotions and the external pressures that shape our interactions, we can better navigate the challenges of working with difficult coworkers, fostering a more supportive and positive work environment.

Frequently Asked Questions Around Dealing with Difficult Coworkers

  1. How can I identify a difficult coworker before a situation escalates? Identifying a difficult coworker early on can help you prepare and respond appropriately. Look for signs such as constant negativity, refusal to cooperate with the team, and a pattern of manipulative or aggressive behavior.
  2. What are some strategies for dealing with a difficult family member at gatherings? While the blog post focuses on workplace dynamics, applying similar strategies such as holding your tongue, taking a moment before responding, and using specific verbal responses can be effective in family gatherings.
  3. Can these tips help with difficult people in online settings, such as social media or virtual meetings? The principles of recognizing difficult personalities and managing your own reactions can be applied in online settings. However, the dynamics may vary, and additional strategies such as limiting engagement or using platform tools to manage interactions might be necessary.
  4. How do I apply these strategies if I’m in a leadership position and the difficult person is under my supervision? Leaders have additional tools at their disposal, such as setting clear behavioral expectations and using formal feedback mechanisms. It’s important to document incidents and follow organizational policies for managing performance and behavior issues.
  5. What should I do if I realize that I might be the difficult coworker? Self-awareness is the first step towards change. Consider seeking feedback, reflecting on your behavior, and possibly consulting a professional for advice on improving your interactions with others.
  6. Are there resources or support systems for dealing with extremely difficult situations, such as harassment or bullying at work? Yes, most organizations should have policies and resources to deal with harassment and bullying. This can include HR departments, employee assistance programs, and in some cases, legal advice. It’s important to document incidents and seek support early.
  7. How can I convince my organization to provide leadership and conflict management training? Presenting the benefits of such training in terms of improved workplace culture, reduced conflict, and increased productivity can help make a case to your organization’s leadership. Highlighting specific issues that could be addressed through training may also be persuasive.
  8. What are some signs that conflict management strategies are working with a difficult person? Signs of progress include a noticeable decrease in confrontational incidents, improved communication, and more positive interactions. It’s also a good sign if the difficult person begins to show awareness of their impact on others.
  9. How can I maintain my professionalism when dealing with a difficult person who is openly disrespectful? Maintaining professionalism involves staying calm, not taking the disrespect personally, and responding in a measured and respectful manner. It may also be necessary to set clear boundaries and involve a supervisor or HR if the behavior continues.
  10. Are there specific techniques for diffusing tension during a heated meeting with a difficult coworker? Techniques include taking a brief pause before responding, redirecting the conversation to the agenda, seeking common ground, or suggesting a break if emotions are running too high. It’s also helpful to address issues directly but respectfully.
  11. How can I tell if I need to escalate a situation involving a difficult person to management or HR? Escalation may be necessary if there’s no improvement despite your best efforts, if the behavior violates company policies, or if it’s affecting your or others’ well-being and productivity significantly.
  12. Can these strategies be applied to clients or customers who are being difficult? Yes, many of these strategies can be adapted for use with clients or customers. It’s important to remain professional, listen actively, and seek solutions that address their concerns while also protecting your boundaries and well-being.
  13. What if the difficult person is my superior? How can I handle the situation without jeopardizing my job? When dealing with a difficult superior, it’s crucial to document interactions, seek support from HR or a mentor within the organization, and focus on clear, respectful communication. Tactfully expressing your perspective and seeking mutual understanding can also be beneficial.
  14. How do I deal with the emotional toll of interacting with a difficult person regularly? Taking care of your mental health is essential. This can include seeking support from friends, family, or a professional; engaging in stress-relief activities; and setting clear boundaries to protect your well-being.
  15. Is it possible to change a difficult person’s behavior, or should I focus on changing how I react to them? While you can employ strategies to influence interactions positively, you have more control over your reactions and boundaries. Focusing on managing your responses and seeking constructive outcomes is often more effective.

Share Our Software With Your Network